Well, after a lot of hemming and hawing (internally), I did go on date #2. I'm not going to lie...I had pretty much already decided there was no potential there, but wanted to keep my word.
I met him there and he gave me an awkward hug. It was weird. Now, I'll totally admit that if he was a hot guy I was super interested in...I wouldn't be complaining, I'd be super excited that he initiated a hug. But...that was not the case.
Once again...there was conversation, but nothing interesting or in common, so it just felt awkward. Also, he told me what dish he liked at this restaurant and asked what type of Italian I like. I told him I was probably going to order the chicken parmesan. To which he replied..."Ooh, that sounds pretty good, I might get that." He thought about it, for a while, then decided he'd stick with his pasta sampler. Well, the waitress comes over to take our order and I order the chicken parmesan. Then he says, "You know what? I'm getting that...yeah, that sounds good. I'll get the same thing."
Now, lest you think I'm the biggest and pickiest jerk on the planet...hear me out. On date #1, he asked what I liked...I told him...and he ordered the exact same thing. On date #2, he does the same? I don't care if people order the same thing as me...but this struck me as odd, like he's not an individual or something.
Our food arrives (it was delish) and it looks like I'm scarfing mine down...while he is taking FOREVER. Same goes for his salad prior to the meal. I assure you that I was eating at a very normal pace. He then says, "I don't know if you've noticed, but I'm a really slow eater. And I just can't eat very big meals. I eat like a bird. But I'm working on it." Um, what? Huh? WHO says any of that? Especially if you're a guy? I thought it was weird and I honestly didn't know what to say to that.
He ended up boxing up half of his meal to take home...while I nearly finished mine. LOL. Oh well.
He had asked what I was doing after dinner, and I mentioned some stuff I needed to get done at home. When I asked him the same...he literally thought about it, for a while, and couldn't come up with anything.
As we wrapped things up, I thanked him for dinner. He then said, "If ya want to get together again, let me know." So, I decided that was my out...and that maybe he was feeling the same thing - that there was no common interests/connection.
Cut to Saturday morning...when he texted me, saying he doesn't date much and he should have invited me out after dinner. Ugh. Nice, but ugh. So, I replied telling him that it was totally fine he didn't invite me (I wouldn't have gone), and that he was a nice guy, but I didn't think we had anything in common. He replied that he thought the same thing.
So, that's that.
On the positive side, it wasn't a nightmare experience and it at least got me back in the game (kind of). On the negative side, it was another failed blind date experience, which is frustrating.
And while I appreciate my friend's attempt at a set-up, his FB message to me made it seem like this guy and I had a lot in common and would totally hit it off. I'm telling you...it would be obvious to anyone that this guy and I would NOT hit it off/have anything in common. And this friend knows me very well.
So, I can only assume that he and his girlfriend (mid 20s) were hanging out with the guy at some point and thought, "He's so great...and he's single...do we know someone to set him up with?" And, of course, I'm the only woman in her late 30s that they know.
People - just because two very nice, fun people are both single does NOT mean they are a potential match for a date or otherwise. If this guy and I had gone out again, it would have been painful for both of us, I'm sure.
Anyway...onward and upward. Right?